# Bitwarden vs Proton Pass (2026): Free Plans, Audits and Aliases

URL: https://plusreviews.net/software/bitwarden-vs-proton-pass/
Category: Software & AI Tools
Author: PlusReviews Editorial Team
Published: 2026-11-19 · Last updated: 2026-11-19

> Bitwarden vs Proton Pass for 2026: free and paid plans, open source, audits, the ETH Zurich study, email aliases, passkeys, family plans and self-hosting.

Disclosure: PlusReviews is reader-supported and may earn a commission from links on this page. As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases.

**Bitwarden is the better pick for most people, and Proton Pass is the better pick if built-in email aliases matter more than price.** Bitwarden's free plan leaves out very little, its paid tiers are among the cheapest of any major password manager, and you can run it on your own server. Proton Pass builds hide-my-email aliases into every plan, including 10 on the free tier, and fits neatly into a Proton Mail or Proton VPN account.

Both are open source, both offer unlimited passwords and devices for free, both store passkeys on the free plan, and both have been audited by outside firms. That makes this an unusually close contest between two privacy-friendly options, and the right answer depends on what you value most: cost and control, or convenience and aliases.

This comparison is research-based. We compared each vendor's pricing pages, help documentation and audit history, plus independent reporting and the 2026 ETH Zurich and USI study, all checked in November 2026. In our pillar guide to the [best password managers](/software/best-password-managers/), Bitwarden ranks [second overall as the best free and best value pick](/software/best-password-managers/#bitwarden) and Proton Pass ranks [third as the best for privacy](/software/best-password-managers/#proton-pass). If you are weighing Bitwarden against the top pick instead, see [1Password vs Bitwarden](/software/1password-vs-bitwarden/).

> **Quick verdict:** - **Choose Bitwarden** if you want the most capable free plan, the cheapest Premium and Families plans, a long public audit record or the option to self-host.
> - **Choose Proton Pass** if you want built-in email aliases, a Swiss provider that also runs your email or VPN, and one login for all of it.
> - **Either is fine** for basic security. Both encrypt your vault on your device, publish their source code and support passkeys for free.

**Bitwarden vs Proton Pass at a glance (November 2026)**

| Password manager | Best for | Free plan | Paid from (renewal) | Family plan | Self-hosting | Where to buy |
| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
| Bitwarden | Free users, budgets and control | Unlimited passwords and devices | $19.80/year (Premium) | 6 people, $47.88/year | Yes | Bitwarden |
| Proton Pass | Email aliases and Proton users | Unlimited logins and devices, 2 vaults, 10 aliases | $35.88/year (Pass Plus) | 6 people, $59.88/year | No | Proton Pass |

## Free plans

Both free plans are good enough that many people never need to pay.

| | Bitwarden Free | Proton Pass Free |
|---|---|---|
| Passwords and devices | Unlimited | Unlimited |
| Passkeys | Yes | Yes |
| Sharing | With one other user | Vaults shared with up to 2 others; no individual item sharing |
| Email aliases | Through outside services such as SimpleLogin, Addy.io or Firefox Relay | 10 built-in hide-my-email aliases |
| Built-in authenticator (2FA codes) | No | No |

**Bitwarden Free** covers unlimited passwords on unlimited devices, passkeys, secure sharing with one other person and its username generator, which can create forwarding aliases through services you connect. **Proton Pass Free** matches it on logins and devices and adds 10 aliases run by Proton itself, but limits you to two vaults and leaves out sharing individual items, the integrated authenticator, emergency access and file attachments, according to Proton's pricing page.

**Our take:** a draw that leans Bitwarden. If you want aliases without signing up for a second service, Proton Pass Free is better; if you want fewer limits overall, Bitwarden is.

## Paid plans and prices

Bitwarden is cheaper at every level once promotions end.

| | Bitwarden | Proton Pass |
|---|---|---|
| Individual plan | Premium: $19.80/year | Pass Plus: $35.88/year at renewal |
| First-year offer (November 2026) | None listed | Pass Plus: $23.88 for the first 12 months |
| Family plan | Families: $47.88/year for 6 people | Pass Family: $59.88/year at renewal for 6 people ($33.48 first year) |
| Bundle | None | Proton Unlimited: $119.88/year at renewal, adds Mail, Calendar, VPN and Drive |
| Authenticator, emergency access, attachments | Included in Premium (5 GB attachments) | Included in Pass Plus (10 GB storage) |
| Aliases | Through outside services | Unlimited built-in aliases |
| Dark web monitoring | Vault health reports | Dark web monitoring and Proton Sentinel |

Prices are from each vendor's US pricing page in November 2026 and exclude tax. Proton was showing first-year discounts when we checked; the renewal price is what you pay from year two, so budget for that.

**Our take:** Bitwarden wins on price. Proton Pass Plus costs more, but unlimited aliases are a real extra, and if you would also pay for Proton Mail or Proton VPN, Proton Unlimited can work out cheaper than buying them separately.

## Open source and audits

Both publish their app source code, and both commission outside audits. Bitwarden's record is longer.

**Bitwarden** lists audits going back to 2018. For 2025 alone, its help center names Cure53 (browser extension, core app, desktop app, web vault and cryptography libraries), ETH Zurich's Applied Cryptography Group (core cryptography, assuming a fully malicious server, which Bitwarden's response indicates is the same research later published as the 2026 study below), Unit 42 at Palo Alto Networks (mobile apps) and Fracture Labs (web app and network). Bitwarden says it has completed SOC 2 Type 2 and SOC 3 audits and is ISO 27001 certified.

**Proton Pass** had its first major audit from Cure53 in 2023. A second, larger audit by German firm Recurity Labs ran from January to April 2026, covering the desktop and mobile apps, the Chrome, Firefox and Safari extensions and the command-line tool. According to CyberInsider, the auditors found no remotely exploitable vulnerabilities and no encryption bypasses, and rated its security posture "well above par". The one medium-rated issue, leftover data on Android after sign-out, was fixed and verified. Most other findings were low severity, many of them in the CLI, and a few low-risk items were still open in the final report, including plaintext usernames in Android local storage, an iOS Keychain fix Proton chose not to deploy yet and credential suggestions across related subdomains. Proton as a company passed its first SOC 2 Type II audit in 2025, according to Tom's Guide.

## The ETH Zurich study: Proton Pass was not in it

The most significant recent research on cloud password managers is a 2026 paper by researchers at ETH Zurich and Università della Svizzera italiana (USI), published on the IACR ePrint archive as the full version of a USENIX Security 2026 paper. It asked whether "zero-knowledge" encryption holds up if the vendor's own server turns malicious, and reported **12 attacks on Bitwarden, 7 on LastPass, 6 on Dashlane and 6 on 1Password**.

**Proton Pass was not included.** The paper analyzed only those four vendors. That means Proton Pass has not been tested under this threat model, not that it would have done better, so do not read its absence as a clean result.

For Bitwarden, the numbers need context:

- **Every attack assumes the server is already under an attacker's control.** These are not attacks someone can run against your vault over the internet today.
- **A count is not a severity score.** Bitwarden's February 2026 response counts ten issues (the paper presents them as twelve attacks), rates them medium or low impact, and says seven are resolved or in remediation while three are design decisions needed for the product to work.
- **Bitwarden worked with the researchers.** Its blog says ETH Zurich selected Bitwarden for analysis mainly because of its open-source architecture, and that it has worked cooperatively with the group to address the findings.

Bitwarden also had a separate incident in April 2026. According to BleepingComputer, a malicious version of the Bitwarden command-line tool was published to the npm package registry for about 90 minutes on April 22, carrying malware aimed at developers' credentials. Bitwarden said its investigation found no evidence that end user vault data was accessed or at risk, or that production systems were compromised, and that people who did not use the npm version of the command-line tool were not affected; it said no other impacted products had been identified. If you are a developer who installed CLI version 2026.4.0, rotate your credentials.

**Our take:** Bitwarden has the deeper audit record, and it also has more published findings because it has been examined more. Proton Pass's 2026 audit is reassuring, but its track record is shorter.

## Email aliases

Aliases let you sign up for a site with a unique forwarding address, so a breach or spam list never gets your real inbox.

**Proton Pass** is the clear winner here. Hide-my-email aliases are built into the app: when you save a new login, Pass can create an alias alongside the password. You get 10 on the free plan and unlimited on paid plans. Proton also owns SimpleLogin, the alias service it acquired in 2022.

**Bitwarden** takes an integration approach. Its username generator can create forwarded aliases through SimpleLogin, Addy.io, Firefox Relay, Fastmail, Forward Email and DuckDuckGo, and the feature is available on every plan, including free. The catch is that you need an account with one of those services, and some charge for more than a handful of aliases.

If aliases are a big part of your privacy plan, they pair well with an encrypted inbox; our [Proton Mail vs Tuta comparison](/software/proton-mail-vs-tuta/) covers the email side.

## Passkeys

Both store and fill passkeys on the free plan, so you do not have to pay to start replacing passwords.

**Bitwarden's** help center says passkeys work in the browser extension, on iOS 17 and later, on Android 14 and later, and in the Windows and macOS desktop apps. On iOS 26 or Android 14 and later, it can move passkeys directly to or from another app that supports the FIDO Credential Exchange Protocol.

**Proton Pass** lists passkeys on every plan, including free, across its apps and browser extensions.

**Our take:** a draw for everyday use. Check current export options before you commit if you think you might switch later.

## Family plans and recovery

Both family plans cover six people with each member getting the full paid feature set.

- **Bitwarden Families** costs $47.88 a year, includes Premium features for all six people, unlimited sharing through collections, 5 GB of personal storage each and 5 GB of shared storage. Emergency access lets a trusted contact request access to your vault after a waiting period you set. Admin-led account recovery, where an administrator resets a member's master password, is only available on Bitwarden's Enterprise plan.
- **Proton Pass Family** renews at $59.88 a year, gives up to six people a full Pass Plus account and includes an admin panel for adding and removing members. Proton's support pages say that if you reset your password, Pass items stay locked until you use a data recovery method you set up beforehand, such as a recovery phrase, a recovery file or a trusted device.

For both, the safest family setup is the same: everyone uses a long, unique master password, turns on two-factor authentication and stores recovery details offline. Our guide to the [best password manager for families](/software/best-password-manager-for-families/) compares these plans with 1Password, Dashlane and NordPass.

## Self-hosting

**Bitwarden** is one of the few mainstream password managers you can run on your own server. Its help center says self-hosting is free, and premium features on a self-hosted server are unlocked with a license file downloaded from an active Bitwarden cloud subscription. That suits technical users and organizations that want full control of where vault data lives, though you then become responsible for updates and backups.

**Proton Pass** cannot be self-hosted; your encrypted vault lives on Proton's servers.

## Bitwarden and Proton Pass in brief

### Bitwarden (Best value)

**Best for:** Anyone who wants the most capable free plan, the cheapest paid tiers or the option to self-host

Pick Bitwarden if you want strong security for little or no money, or control over where your vault is stored. Skip it if you want aliases built in, or the most polished interface. Our main guide has more on [Bitwarden's plans](/software/best-password-managers/#bitwarden).

**Pros:**
- Free plan with unlimited passwords and devices, plus passkeys
- Premium costs $19.80 a year and Families $47.88 a year for six people
- Open source with audits listed almost every year since 2018
- Can be self-hosted for free

**Cons:**
- No built-in aliases; you need an account with an outside alias service
- Most attacks (12) of the four vendors in the 2026 ETH Zurich and USI malicious-server study
- A malicious CLI release reached npm in April 2026, though Bitwarden says it found no evidence vault data was accessed
- Admin account recovery is Enterprise-only, so a forgotten master password on Families can mean lost data

| Spec | Value |
| --- | --- |
| Free plan | Unlimited passwords and devices |
| Premium | $19.80/year |
| Families | $47.88/year, 6 people |
| Self-hosting | Yes |

Available at: Bitwarden

### Proton Pass (Best for aliases and privacy)

**Best for:** Privacy-focused users and Proton Mail or Proton VPN customers who want email aliases built into their password manager

Pick Proton Pass if aliases are central to how you protect your inbox, or if you already pay for Proton. Skip it if you want the lowest price, self-hosting or the longest audit history. See the [Proton Pass section of our main guide](/software/best-password-managers/#proton-pass) for more.

**Pros:**
- 10 built-in hide-my-email aliases on the free plan and unlimited on paid plans
- Free plan with unlimited logins, devices and passkeys
- Open-source apps, audited by Cure53 in 2023 and Recurity Labs in 2026
- Shares one account with Proton Mail, VPN and Drive

**Cons:**
- Free plan limited to 2 vaults, with no item sharing or built-in authenticator
- Pass Plus renews at $35.88 a year, almost twice Bitwarden Premium
- Not included in the 2026 ETH Zurich study, and a shorter audit record than Bitwarden
- Cannot be self-hosted

| Spec | Value |
| --- | --- |
| Free plan | Unlimited logins, 2 vaults, 10 aliases |
| Pass Plus | $35.88/year at renewal |
| Pass Family | $59.88/year at renewal, 6 people |
| Self-hosting | No |

Available at: Proton Pass

## Who should pick which

- **You want the best free password manager:** Bitwarden, for the fewest restrictions. Proton Pass Free is the better free choice only if you want built-in aliases.
- **You want premium features for the least money:** Bitwarden Premium at $19.80 a year.
- **You want an alias for every sign-up:** Proton Pass Plus.
- **You already use Proton Mail or Proton VPN:** Proton Pass, or Proton Unlimited if you want the paid tiers of everything.
- **You want to self-host:** Bitwarden.
- **You are covering a family of six on a budget:** Bitwarden Families.

A password manager protects your accounts, not your traffic or your public footprint. A [trustworthy VPN](/software/best-vpn-services/) helps on public Wi-Fi, and a [data removal service](/software/best-data-removal-services/) cuts down what data brokers sell about you.

## How we researched this comparison

We did not run our own tests of either app. We compared Bitwarden and Proton Pass using their pricing pages and help documentation, Bitwarden's audit listing and response to the ETH Zurich study, the study itself on the IACR ePrint archive, and reporting from CyberInsider, BleepingComputer and Tom's Guide, all checked in November 2026. Both companies may have affiliate programs, which did not affect the verdict; see our [editorial policy](/editorial-policy/) and [affiliate disclosure](/affiliate-disclosure/).

## Bottom line

**Bitwarden** is the better value: a free plan with few restrictions, Premium for $19.80 a year, a long public audit record and self-hosting if you want it. **Proton Pass** is the better privacy package for people who want aliases built in and already trust Proton with their email or VPN. Both are solid, open-source choices, and both free plans are worth trying before you pay.

(available at Bitwarden)

(available at Proton Pass)

## FAQ

**Is Bitwarden or Proton Pass better?**
Bitwarden is better for most people who want the strongest free plan or the cheapest paid tiers, and it is the only one of the two you can self-host. Proton Pass is better if you want built-in email aliases or a password manager that shares an account with Proton Mail and Proton VPN.

**Which has the better free plan, Bitwarden or Proton Pass?**
Both free plans include unlimited passwords, unlimited devices and passkeys. Bitwarden's free plan lets you generate aliases through outside services such as SimpleLogin or Firefox Relay. Proton Pass Free adds 10 built-in hide-my-email aliases but limits you to 2 vaults and leaves out item sharing and the built-in authenticator.

**Was Proton Pass included in the ETH Zurich password manager study?**
No. The 2026 study by ETH Zurich and USI researchers analyzed Bitwarden, LastPass, Dashlane and 1Password, reporting 12 attacks on Bitwarden under a malicious-server threat model. Proton Pass was not part of it, which means it was not tested under that model, not that it would have passed.

**How much do Bitwarden and Proton Pass cost?**
Bitwarden Premium costs $19.80 a year and Bitwarden Families $47.88 a year for six people. Proton Pass Plus renews at $35.88 a year and Pass Family at $59.88 a year for six people, with lower first-year promotional prices for new subscribers.

**Can I self-host Bitwarden or Proton Pass?**
You can self-host Bitwarden, and the software is free to run on your own server; premium features on a self-hosted server are unlocked with a license file from a paid cloud subscription. Proton Pass is cloud-only and cannot be self-hosted.

## Sources

- [Bitwarden pricing (Bitwarden)](https://bitwarden.com/pricing/) — Free, Premium $19.80/yr and Families $47.88/yr for 6 users; self-host options; alias integration on all plans; checked November 2026
- [Username and password generator (Bitwarden Help Center)](https://bitwarden.com/help/generator/) — forwarded email alias services supported, available to all users
- [License paid features for self-hosting (Bitwarden Help Center)](https://bitwarden.com/help/licensing-on-premise/) — self-hosting is free; premium features need a license file from an active cloud subscription
- [Is Bitwarden audited? (Bitwarden Help Center)](https://bitwarden.com/help/is-bitwarden-audited/) — 2025 audits by Cure53, ETH Zurich, Unit 42 and Fracture Labs; SOC 2 Type 2 and ISO 27001
- [Security through transparency: ETH Zurich audits Bitwarden cryptography (Bitwarden)](https://bitwarden.com/blog/security-through-transparency-eth-zurich-audits-bitwarden-cryptography/) — February 16, 2026; vendor response, ten issues counted, seven fixed or in remediation, three design decisions
- [Zero Knowledge (About) Encryption (IACR ePrint 2026/058)](https://eprint.iacr.org/2026/058) — ETH Zurich and USI; Bitwarden, LastPass, Dashlane and 1Password analyzed; Proton Pass not included
- [Bitwarden CLI npm package compromised to steal developer credentials (BleepingComputer)](https://www.bleepingcomputer.com/news/security/bitwarden-cli-npm-package-compromised-to-steal-developer-credentials/) — April 23, 2026; malicious CLI release on npm for about 90 minutes; Bitwarden found no evidence vault data was affected
- [Bitwarden statement on Checkmarx supply chain incident (Bitwarden Community)](https://community.bitwarden.com/t/bitwarden-statement-on-checkmarx-supply-chain-incident/96127) — only users who downloaded the npm CLI package in the window were affected; no other impacted products identified
- [Proton AG acquires SimpleLogin (gHacks)](https://www.ghacks.net/2022/04/09/proton-ag-acquires-simplelogin-email-alias-service/) — April 9, 2022 acquisition
- [Storing passkeys (Bitwarden Help Center)](https://bitwarden.com/help/storing-passkeys/) — passkey platforms and Credential Exchange on mobile
- [Proton Pass pricing (Proton)](https://proton.me/pass/pricing) — Free, Pass Plus, Pass Family and Unlimited first-year and renewal prices and feature limits, checked November 2026
- [Proton Pass rated well above par in independent security audit (CyberInsider)](https://cyberinsider.com/proton-pass-rated-well-above-par-in-independent-security-audit/) — May 13, 2026; Recurity Labs audit, January to April 2026
- [Proton Pass open source and security audit (Proton)](https://proton.me/blog/pass-open-source-security-audit) — Cure53 audit, 2023
- [Proton passes its first SOC 2 Type II audit (Tom's Guide)](https://www.tomsguide.com/computing/online-security/proton-passes-its-first-soc-2-type-ii-audit-verifying-its-business-security-credentials) — Proton's first SOC 2 Type II audit, 2025
- [Recover encrypted data after a password reset (Proton Support)](https://proton.me/support/recover-encrypted-messages-files) — Proton Pass items need a data recovery method after a password reset
