Software & AI ToolsComparison
Optery vs Incogni: Which Data Removal Service Is Better?
Optery vs Incogni for 2026: how each removes your data, broker coverage, proof of removal, pricing, free scans and what the Consumer Reports study found.
By PlusReviews Editorial TeamPublished 9 min read8 sources
Disclosure: PlusReviews is reader-supported. When you buy through links on this page we may earn an affiliate commission, at no extra cost to you. Our picks are based on independent research. How we make money.
Optery is the better data removal service for most people in the US, and Incogni is the better choice for readers in the UK and Europe or anyone who wants the most hands-off approach. Optery lets you check your exposure for free, starts at $39 a year, and shows screenshots of where your profiles were found, with before-and-after removal screenshots on its Extended and Ultimate plans. Incogni sends recurring deletion requests to 420+ data brokers, including private brokers you cannot search for yourself, and works in more countries.
That matches our guide to the best data removal services, where Optery ranks first overall and Incogni second as the best hands-off option. The real difference between them is philosophy: Optery emphasizes showing you proof, while Incogni emphasizes breadth and automation.
This comparison is research-based. We did not run our own removal tests; we compared each company’s published plans, coverage claims and documentation as of November 2026, Deloitte’s 2025 assurance report on Incogni, and the 2024 Consumer Reports study of removal services. If you are also securing your accounts, our 1Password vs Bitwarden comparison covers the two leading password managers.
| Service | Best for | Automated coverage (vendor claim) | Price from (billed yearly) | Free option | Price |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Optery | US residents who want proof of removal | 375+ to 620+ sites, by plan | $39/year (Core) | Free Basic plan with exposure reports | See plans at Optery(opens in a new tab) |
| Incogni | Hands-off removal, UK, EU and Canada | 420+ brokers on every plan | $95.88/year (Standard) | No plan; free one-off scan and 30-day refund | See plans at Incogni(opens in a new tab) |
How each service works
Optery: scan, remove, prove
Optery starts with a free account. You enter your first and last name, city, state and birth year, and Optery emails an exposure report, which it says usually arrives within a few hours, showing which people-search sites list you. That report includes screenshots of the listings it found.
On a paid plan, Optery runs monthly automated scans and submits opt-outs to the sites in your plan. Its Extended and Ultimate plans add an assigned human privacy agent for tricky cases and send removal reports with before-and-after screenshots roughly every 90 days. Optery says it holds an AICPA SOC 2 Type II certification.
Incogni: request, follow up, repeat
Incogni’s process is built around deletion requests rather than search results. According to its homepage, it finds where your details appear on public people-search sites, sends removal requests and follows up, while its ongoing Exposure Scanner, which lists found exposures alongside a Privacy Score, is part of the Unlimited plans. For private data brokers, which sell to marketers and do not publish searchable profiles, it uses details such as your region to work out which brokers are likely to hold your data and sends them opt-out requests on a schedule.
Your dashboard tracks each request with statuses such as “Request sent”, “Awaiting reply”, “Removal confirmed” and “Relisted / Request resent”, along with each broker’s expected removal time. All plans include monthly progress reports, and the Unlimited plans add the Privacy Score, which updates every 30 days.
Broker coverage and rescans
| Optery | Incogni | |
|---|---|---|
| Automated coverage | 375+ sites (Core), 550+ (Extended), 620+ (Ultimate) | 420+ brokers on every plan |
| Without optional settings | 150+ (Core), 325+ (Extended), 395+ (Ultimate) without Optery’s “Expanded Reach” | Not applicable |
| Custom removal requests | Unlimited on Ultimate only, after 30 days | Unlimited on Unlimited and Family Unlimited |
| How often it rechecks | Monthly scans and removals on paid plans | Requests resent at least every 60 days for public brokers and 90 days for private brokers (per Deloitte’s 2025 assurance) |
| Names and addresses covered | Core: one name and city/state; Extended and Ultimate: unlimited names and past cities | Not specified on the pricing page |
| Countries | US, Canada (excluding Quebec), Australia, New Zealand, South Africa | US and territories, Canada, UK, EU, Switzerland, Norway, Iceland, Liechtenstein |
Two things stand out. First, Optery’s headline counts depend on its plan and on an optional “Expanded Reach” setting; its pricing page lists much lower figures without it. Second, the two companies count differently. Incogni says its 420+ includes private brokers that you would never find by searching your own name, while Optery’s reports center on listings it can find and screenshot.
Neither number is a measure of how many listings actually get removed. Treat broker counts as marketing figures and pay more attention to evidence of results.
Proof of removal
This is the clearest difference between the services.
Optery shows you evidence. Its exposure reports include screenshots of where your profiles were found, and on Extended and Ultimate the removal reports include before-and-after screenshots. You can see for yourself whether a listing is gone, rather than trusting a status label.
Incogni shows you request status. You can see which brokers it contacted, which replied and which confirmed removal, and when a listing reappeared and a new request went out. That is useful, especially for private brokers, where there is no public profile to screenshot. But it is a record of requests and confirmations, not visual proof.
Incogni does have outside verification of its process. In August 2025, Deloitte provided limited assurance that Incogni covered more than 420 brokers with deletion requests, received removal confirmations from more than 420 of them, and resent requests at intervals of no more than 60 days for public brokers and 90 days for private brokers. Deloitte also covered Incogni’s statement that it did not sell customer data in 2024. The assurance covers the process, not what share of listings actually disappeared.
Pricing and plans
| Plan | Optery (billed yearly) | Incogni (billed yearly) |
|---|---|---|
| Free | Basic: quarterly exposure reports and self-service opt-out links | No free plan |
| Entry plan | Core: $39/year, 375+ sites | Standard: $95.88/year ($7.99/mo), 420+ brokers |
| Mid plan | Extended: $149/year, 550+ sites and a human privacy agent | Unlimited: $179.88/year ($14.99/mo), adds custom removals and exposure scanner |
| Top plan | Ultimate: $249/year, 620+ sites plus unlimited custom removals | Not applicable |
| Family | Family plans listed; check Optery’s family page for pricing | Family: $191.88/year; Family Unlimited: $275.88/year; up to 5 people |
| Refund | 30-day money-back guarantee on paid plans | 30-day money-back guarantee |
Prices are from each company’s pricing page in November 2026. Both also offer monthly billing at a higher effective price. Optery says yearly billing saves 17%, and Incogni notes that monthly billing is less thorough because some broker requests take more than 30 days to process. Check the current pricing pages before buying, as both companies change prices and run promotions.
For one person, Optery Core is the cheapest way into either service by a wide margin. Optery Extended and Incogni Unlimited are closer in price; Incogni Unlimited includes custom removals, which Optery reserves for Ultimate.
Free scans and free plans
Optery has the stronger free offer. Its free Basic account sends quarterly exposure reports with screenshots and gives you links to opt out of sites yourself. You can use Optery free indefinitely as a checklist for manual opt-outs and only pay if you want the work automated.
Incogni has no free plan or trial. Its homepage offers a free one-off exposure scan without creating an account, and its ongoing exposure scanner with a Privacy Score is part of the Unlimited plans. If you buy and change your mind, Incogni offers a full refund within 30 days.
What the Consumer Reports study found
In August 2024, Consumer Reports published a study of people-search removal services. According to The Record’s coverage, 32 volunteers in California and New York took part over four months: 28 were assigned to removal services and four did their own opt-outs. The services tested were Optery, EasyOptOuts, DeleteMe, IDX, Kanary, Confidently and ReputationDefender, priced from $19.99 to $249 a year.
The headline finding was sobering for the whole category: across the services, only 117 of 332 listings, about 35%, were removed within four months. EasyOptOuts and Optery were the two best performers, DeleteMe, IDX and Kanary were mid-level, and Confidently and ReputationDefender were the least effective. According to Optery’s own published summary of the data, it removed 68% of listings at four months, against 65% for EasyOptOuts and 27% for DeleteMe. Optery’s statement notes that Consumer Reports concluded doing opt-outs yourself was more effective than the services, and The Record reports that CR found financial partnerships between some removal services and the people-search sites they remove listings from.
How to read it fairly:
- Incogni was not tested. The study tells you nothing about Incogni’s results, good or bad. It is a point in Optery’s favor that it performed well when tested, not evidence that Optery beats Incogni.
- The sample was small. Thirty-two volunteers and a limited set of people-search sites is a useful snapshot, not a definitive ranking.
- Optery disputes the manual comparison. It argues the manual opt-outs were done by experienced privacy researchers rather than ordinary consumers, and that services were given limited information about participants. Optery is an interested party, so weigh its critique accordingly.
- The study is from 2024. Both services have changed their plans and coverage since then.
Optery and Incogni in brief
Best for proof of removal
Optery
Best for US residents who want to see their exposure for free and get screenshot evidence of removals
Pick Optery if you want to check your exposure before paying and see proof that listings were removed. Skip it if you live in the UK or Europe, or want custom removals without paying for the top plan. There is more detail in the Optery section of our main guide.
- Plans
- Core $39, Extended $149, Ultimate $249 per year
- Coverage
- 375+ to 620+ sites
- Free plan
- Yes, Basic
- Rescans
- Monthly on paid plans
Pros
- Free Basic plan with quarterly exposure reports and screenshots
- Paid plans from $39 a year, the cheapest entry point of the two
- Before-and-after screenshot reports on Extended and Ultimate
- One of the two best performers in the 2024 Consumer Reports study
Cons
- Not available in the UK or EU
- Headline site counts depend on plan and the optional Expanded Reach setting
- Custom removals only on the $249 Ultimate plan
- Core covers one name and city/state only, and before-and-after removal screenshots start on the $149 Extended plan
Best hands-off option
Incogni
Best for People who want recurring requests to public and private brokers, including in the UK, EU and Canada
Pick Incogni if you want a set-and-forget service, live outside Optery’s supported countries, or care about private brokers that never show a public profile. Skip it if screenshot proof of removal matters most to you; Optery provides that from its $149 Extended plan. Our main guide has a fuller Incogni breakdown.
- Standard
- $95.88/year
- Unlimited
- $179.88/year
- Family
- $191.88/year, up to 5 people
- Guarantee
- 30-day money-back
Pros
- 420+ brokers on every plan, including private marketing brokers
- Deloitte limited assurance on its process and request intervals in 2025
- Available in the US, Canada, UK, EU, Switzerland and more
- Family plans cover up to five people
Cons
- No free plan; the base Standard plan costs more than Optery Core
- Shows request statuses rather than screenshot proof
- Custom removals and the ongoing exposure scanner need an Unlimited plan
- Not included in the 2024 Consumer Reports study, so there is no comparable independent result
Who should pick which
- You want to know how exposed you are before paying: Optery’s free Basic plan.
- You want the cheapest paid automation: Optery Core at $39 a year. If price is everything, EasyOptOuts in our pillar guide is cheaper still.
- You live in the UK, EU or Switzerland: Incogni.
- You live in Australia, New Zealand or South Africa: Optery.
- You want proof, not status updates: Optery Extended or Ultimate.
- You want to cover a household: Incogni Family covers up to five people on one plan; Optery lists family plans too, so compare current pricing.
- You are dealing with harassment or stalking: prioritize custom removals and human help, which means Optery Ultimate or Incogni Unlimited, and consider pairing either with manual opt-outs for the sites that matter most to you.
Removing broker listings is one part of protecting yourself. Unique passwords in a password manager and a trustworthy VPN on public Wi-Fi close gaps that no removal service can.
How we researched this comparison
We did not run our own removal tests, and we do not report success rates of our own. We compared Optery and Incogni using their pricing pages, home pages and help documentation (checked in November 2026), Incogni’s published summary of Deloitte’s 2025 limited assurance report, The Record’s reporting on the 2024 Consumer Reports study and Optery’s published statement on that study. Consumer Reports’ own report pages were not accessible to us, so the study details come from The Record’s reporting and the per-service figures from Optery’s summary. Both companies may have affiliate programs, which did not affect the verdict; see our editorial policy and affiliate disclosure.
Bottom line
Start with Optery if you live in the US: its free plan shows you where you are exposed, its paid plans start low, and its screenshots let you check the results. Choose Incogni if you live in the UK or Europe, or want recurring requests sent to private brokers with as little involvement as possible. Neither service can erase you from the internet, but either one reduces how easy you are to find.
Scan free with Optery(opens in a new tab) Visit Incogni(opens in a new tab)Frequently asked questions
Is Optery or Incogni better?
For most people in the US, Optery is the better pick because it has a free plan, cheaper entry pricing at $39 a year, free exposure reports with screenshots, and before-and-after removal screenshots on its Extended and Ultimate plans. Incogni is the better pick if you live in the UK, EU or Switzerland, or if you want broad, hands-off requests to private data brokers you cannot search yourself.
Was Incogni included in the Consumer Reports study?
No. Consumer Reports' 2024 study tested seven services: Optery, EasyOptOuts, DeleteMe, IDX, Kanary, Confidently and ReputationDefender. Incogni was not one of them, so the study says nothing about how Incogni performs.
Does Incogni have a free plan?
No. Incogni has no free plan or free trial, but its paid plans come with a 30-day money-back guarantee, and its website offers a free one-off exposure scan without an account. Optery's free Basic plan includes quarterly exposure reports and self-service opt-out links.
How much do Optery and Incogni cost?
Billed yearly, Optery costs $39 (Core), $149 (Extended) or $249 (Ultimate) a year. Incogni costs $95.88 (Standard) or $179.88 (Unlimited) a year for one person, and $191.88 or $275.88 a year for family plans covering up to five people.
Can Optery or Incogni remove public records?
No. Data removal services send opt-out and deletion requests to data brokers and people-search sites. They cannot delete government records such as property or court filings, and they cannot remove data held by companies you have an account with.
Sources
The specifications, test results and documentation this guide draws on:
- Optery plans and pricing (Optery) — Free Basic, Core, Extended and Ultimate features, site counts and yearly prices
- Optery home page (Optery) — free exposure report, screenshot reports, monthly scans, SOC 2 Type II
- Does Optery work in other countries than the United States? (Optery Help Center) — supported countries, updated September 2026
- Optery statement on the Consumer Reports people-search removal study (Optery) — per-service removal rates and Optery's critique; Optery is an interested party
- Consumer Reports study finds data removal services are often ineffective (The Record) — 32 volunteers, services tested, 35% of listings removed after four months
- Incogni pricing (Incogni) — Standard, Unlimited and Family plans; supported countries; 30-day money-back guarantee
- Incogni home page (Incogni) — how it works, request statuses, free exposure scan, private brokers
- Deloitte limited assurance report on Incogni (Incogni blog) — August 2025; 420+ brokers, recurring request intervals