Software & AI ToolsComparison
Proton Mail vs Tuta (2026): Encryption, Price and Privacy Compared
Proton Mail vs Tuta for 2026: what each encrypts, post-quantum keys, IMAP and PGP, free plans, prices, custom domains, Swiss vs German law and the wider apps.
By PlusReviews Editorial TeamPublished 9 min read16 sources
Disclosure: PlusReviews is reader-supported. When you buy through links on this page we may earn an affiliate commission, at no extra cost to you. Our picks are based on independent research. How we make money.
Proton Mail is the better choice for most people, and Tuta is the better choice if you want as much of your mailbox encrypted as possible for less money. Proton works more like a normal email service: it supports PGP, connects to Outlook or Thunderbird through its Bridge app on paid plans, and sits inside a wider suite with Drive, VPN, Pass and Calendar. Tuta encrypts more by default, including subject lines, contacts and calendar entries, has used post-quantum keys for new accounts since 2024 and costs less, but it only works in its own apps.
Both are end-to-end encrypted services run by privacy-focused European companies, and both offer a free plan with 1 GB of storage. For most readers the choice comes down to three questions: do you need subject lines and contacts encrypted, do you need to use a desktop email client or PGP, and do you want an email service or a whole privacy suite?
This comparison is research-based. We compared each provider’s encryption documentation, pricing pages and reporting on how they have handled legal orders, checked in November 2026. Both services appear in our pillar guide to the best encrypted email services, where Proton Mail ranks first overall and Tuta is our pick for the most encrypted mailbox.
| Service | Best for | Subject lines encrypted | Desktop clients (IMAP) | Paid from | Jurisdiction | Price |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Proton Mail | Flexibility and the wider Proton suite | No | Yes, via Bridge on paid plans | $29.88 first year, then $47.88/yr (Mail Plus) | Switzerland | See plans at Proton Mail(opens in a new tab) |
| Tuta | Maximum encryption on a budget | Yes | No | €3/mo billed yearly (Revolutionary) | Germany | See plans at Tuta(opens in a new tab) |
What each service actually encrypts
Both services encrypt message bodies and attachments so that the company storing them cannot read them. The differences are in everything around the message.
| Proton Mail | Tuta | |
|---|---|---|
| Message body and attachments | End-to-end between Proton users; zero-access for mail arriving from other providers | End-to-end |
| Subject lines | Not end-to-end encrypted | Encrypted |
| Contacts | Encrypted, except names and email addresses, which are signed | Encrypted |
| Calendar | Event title, description, location and attendees encrypted | Encrypted, including reminders |
| Sender and recipient addresses | Visible to Proton | Visible to Tuta |
| Mail to Gmail or Outlook users | Password-protected messages or PGP | Password-protected messages |
Tuta says subject lines, contacts and calendars are all end-to-end encrypted, along with the message itself, and that even reminder notification times are hidden from its servers. Search works through an encrypted index stored on your own device. What Tuta cannot encrypt is the sender and recipient addresses, because email servers need them to deliver mail.
Proton Mail encrypts message content and attachments, and Proton says it cannot read your emails or hand them to anyone else. But subject lines are not end-to-end encrypted. When The Register covered Proton’s 2021 legal case, it noted that Proton’s privacy policy lists sender and recipient addresses, the IP address incoming mail came from, subject lines and send and receive times as data it can access. In Proton Contacts, names and email addresses are digitally signed so tampering can be detected, but not encrypted; every other contact field, such as phone numbers and notes, is encrypted. Proton Calendar encrypts event titles, descriptions, locations and attendees.
Our take: Tuta wins this round. If you would not want a subject line like “Biopsy results” or “Lawyer meeting” readable to your provider, Tuta is the safer home for it.
Post-quantum encryption
Post-quantum encryption is meant to stop “harvest now, decrypt later” attacks, where someone stores encrypted mail today hoping a future quantum computer can break it.
Tuta moved first. Its security page says it replaced RSA with a hybrid of x25519 and Kyber-1024, so mail stays protected unless both are broken. Tuta’s TutaCrypt protocol launched for new accounts in March 2024, and CyberInsider reports that Tuta says all existing accounts were migrated by March 2026. In an August 2026 analysis covered by CyberInsider, researchers at the University of Wuppertal concluded that the protocol provides meaningful post-quantum confidentiality, while noting it lacks some forward secrecy protections that Tuta is still working on.
Proton Mail added optional post-quantum protection in May 2026, available on every plan, including free. You turn it on in your encryption settings. According to Help Net Security, it generates new keys for new encrypted email but does not re-encrypt messages already in your mailbox, needs up-to-date apps, and pauses end-to-end encrypted forwarding while it is on.
Our take: Tuta is ahead because its protection is on by default and covers existing accounts. Proton has closed much of the gap, but only if you switch it on.
Apps, IMAP and PGP
This is where Proton Mail pulls clearly ahead.
Proton Mail supports PGP, so you can exchange encrypted mail with anyone who uses PGP elsewhere, and you can send password-protected messages to people who do not. On paid plans, the Proton Mail Bridge app lets you use desktop clients such as Outlook, Apple Mail or Thunderbird. Bridge is not available on the free plan.
Tuta does neither. It does not use PGP, and it does not offer IMAP or support third-party email clients, because it says that would require sending decrypted data to your device. You read mail in Tuta’s web, desktop, Android and iOS apps, whose code is published on GitHub. You can still write securely to non-Tuta users by setting a shared password on the message.
Our take: Proton Mail wins. If you live in a desktop email client, work with PGP users or want to back up mail with standard tools, Tuta is a poor fit.
Free plans
Both free plans use the same encryption as the paid ones, and both are fine for a private personal address.
- Proton Free: 1 GB of storage (500 MB at first, rising to 1 GB once you complete a short setup checklist), one address and up to 150 messages a day, with no custom domain and no Bridge, according to Proton’s pricing page.
- Tuta Free: 1 GB of storage, one calendar and three labels, with no extra addresses and no custom domain, according to Tuta’s pricing page.
Proton’s free account also gets you into its free VPN, Pass and Drive tiers with the same login. Proton’s support pages say free accounts inactive for more than 24 months can be deleted, and advise signing in at least once a year, and Tuta also has an inactivity policy for free accounts, so log in now and then or upgrade if you rely on the address.
Paid plans, prices and custom domains
Tuta is cheaper at every level, but Proton’s bundle includes much more than email.
| Proton Mail | Tuta | |
|---|---|---|
| Entry paid plan | Mail Plus: $29.88 first year, then $47.88/yr | Revolutionary: €3/mo billed yearly, or €3.60 monthly |
| Entry plan storage | 15 GB | 20 GB |
| Extra addresses (entry plan) | 10 addresses | 15 alias addresses |
| Custom domains (entry plan) | 1 | 3 |
| Top personal plan | Unlimited: $77.88 first year, then $119.88/yr, 500 GB, 3 custom domains | Legend: €8/mo billed yearly, or €9.60 monthly, 500 GB, 10 custom domains |
| Family options | Proton Family plan for up to six people | Add users to a paid plan at €3 (Revolutionary) or €8 (Legend) per user a month |
Proton’s prices are from its US pricing page; the first-year rates apply to new subscribers, so budget for the renewal price. Tuta lists its prices in euros; the monthly figures come from Tuta’s August 2026 plan comparison, and the storage, alias and domain limits from its pricing page. Tuta did not show a separate renewal price on the pages we checked, but promotions run, so confirm what you will pay in year two.
Custom domains matter more than they look: if you use your own domain, you can change provider later without changing your address. Tuta’s Revolutionary plan includes three, against one on Proton Mail Plus.
Jurisdiction and legal history
Proton is based in Geneva, Switzerland. In 2021, a legally binding Swiss order, executed on behalf of French authorities, led Proton to log a climate activist’s IP address and device information; message content stayed encrypted, and Proton changed its privacy policy afterwards to say it can be compelled to log IP addresses. In 2025 Proton said legal uncertainty over a proposed revision of Swiss surveillance rules was leading it to move some physical infrastructure out of Switzerland, starting with its Lumo AI assistant. It later clarified to CyberInsider that it is not making a gradual exit and that its headquarters stay in Geneva.
Tuta is based in Germany and stores data in ISO 27001-certified data centers there. In late 2020, the Cologne Regional Court ordered Tuta to provide future unencrypted incoming and outgoing mail for one mailbox, according to The Register. In 2021, Germany’s Federal Court of Justice dismissed Tuta’s appeal against the Cologne ruling, in a decision CyberScoop reported as covering two accounts tied to a blackmail case for three months. Tuta said it could not decrypt end-to-end encrypted mail, and the orders covered only unencrypted messages.
Our take: call it even. Both companies have been compelled to help police in narrow cases, and in both, encrypted content stayed protected. That is the real lesson: what a provider cannot read, it cannot hand over. If you want to keep your IP address away from your email provider, use a trustworthy VPN such as Proton VPN or another pick from our VPN guide.
Ecosystem: Proton’s suite vs Tuta’s focused apps
Proton has grown into a full privacy suite. One Proton account covers Mail, Calendar, Drive, VPN and Pass, and the Proton Unlimited plan bundles the paid tiers of all of them. If you were already considering a password manager, our Bitwarden vs Proton Pass comparison shows how Proton Pass stacks up, and Unlimited can be cheaper than buying a VPN and password manager separately.
Tuta is deliberately narrower: Mail, Calendar and Contacts, all encrypted. Its encrypted cloud storage, Tuta Drive, was still in closed beta when we checked its site in November 2026, with a public launch promised “in a few months”. If you want encrypted email and calendar without being pulled into a bigger subscription, that focus is a plus.
Proton Mail and Tuta in brief
Best for most people
Proton Mail
Best for People who want strong encryption that still works with PGP, desktop email clients and a wider privacy suite
Pick Proton Mail if you want encrypted email that fits into how you already work, or if you plan to use more than one Proton app. Skip it if encrypted subject lines matter to you, or if you need a desktop email client on a free plan.
- Free plan
- 1 GB, 1 address, 150 messages/day
- Mail Plus
- $29.88 first year, then $47.88/yr
- Custom domains
- 1 (Mail Plus), 3 (Unlimited)
- Jurisdiction
- Switzerland
Pros
- End-to-end encryption between Proton users, plus password-protected email to anyone
- PGP support and desktop email clients through Bridge on paid plans
- Optional post-quantum keys on every plan since May 2026
- One account covers Mail, Calendar, Drive, VPN and Pass
Cons
- Subject lines are not end-to-end encrypted, and contact names and email addresses are only signed
- Mail Plus renews at $47.88 a year after a $29.88 first year
- Post-quantum protection is off by default and does not cover existing mail
- Logged a user's IP address under a Swiss order in 2021
Most encrypted mailbox
Tuta
Best for Privacy-focused users who want subject lines, contacts and calendar encrypted at a low price
Pick Tuta if you want the most of your mailbox encrypted and are happy to use its own apps. Skip it if you rely on Outlook, Thunderbird or PGP, or want your email bundled with a VPN and password manager.
- Free plan
- 1 GB, 1 calendar
- Revolutionary
- €3/mo yearly or €3.60 monthly
- Custom domains
- 3 (Revolutionary), 10 (Legend)
- Jurisdiction
- Germany
Pros
- Encrypts subject lines, contacts and calendar entries, not just message bodies
- Post-quantum keys by default, and Tuta says all accounts were migrated by March 2026
- Revolutionary costs €3 a month billed yearly, with 20 GB and 3 custom domains
- Open-source apps on every major platform
Cons
- No PGP, so you cannot exchange encrypted mail natively with PGP users
- No IMAP or third-party email clients
- Ordered by German courts to hand over future unencrypted mail for specific accounts in 2020 and 2021
- Narrower ecosystem, with Tuta Drive still in closed beta
Who should pick which
- You want encryption with minimal change to your habits: Proton Mail, especially if you use a desktop client.
- You care most about what your provider can see: Tuta, for encrypted subject lines and contacts.
- You exchange mail with PGP users: Proton Mail. Tuta cannot.
- You want your own domain cheaply: Tuta Revolutionary, with three custom domains.
- You want one privacy subscription for everything: Proton Unlimited.
- You worry about future quantum attacks: Tuta today; Proton if you turn on its post-quantum option.
Whichever you pick, protect the account itself with a long, unique password stored in a password manager, turn on two-factor authentication and keep your recovery details offline. Encrypted email also does nothing about the personal details data brokers already hold; a data removal service tackles that.
How we researched this comparison
This comparison does not report results from our own long-term use of either service. We compared Proton Mail and Tuta using their security documentation, support pages and pricing pages, checked in November 2026, together with reporting from The Register, CyberScoop, CyberInsider and Help Net Security on legal orders, infrastructure changes and post-quantum encryption. Tuta’s monthly prices come from its own August 2026 plan comparison, because its pricing page did not display base prices when we checked. Both companies may have affiliate programs, and that did not influence the verdict; see our editorial policy and affiliate disclosure.
Bottom line
Proton Mail is the better all-rounder: PGP, desktop clients through Bridge, optional post-quantum keys and a suite of privacy apps under one account. Tuta is the more private mailbox and the cheaper one, with encrypted subject lines, contacts and calendars and post-quantum protection on by default, as long as you can live without PGP and third-party clients. Both free plans are good enough to try before you pay.
See Proton Mail's plans(opens in a new tab) See Tuta's plans(opens in a new tab)Frequently asked questions
Is Proton Mail or Tuta more private?
Tuta encrypts more of your mailbox. Subject lines, contacts and calendar entries are all end-to-end encrypted, while Proton Mail leaves subject lines readable to Proton and only signs, rather than encrypts, contact names and email addresses. Both encrypt message bodies and attachments so the provider cannot read them, and neither can hide sender and recipient addresses.
Does Proton Mail have post-quantum encryption like Tuta?
Yes, since May 2026, but it is optional. Proton Mail users on any plan, including free, can turn on post-quantum keys in their settings; the protection applies to new encrypted mail, not to messages already in the mailbox. Tuta has used post-quantum keys by default for new accounts since March 2024 and says all existing accounts were migrated by March 2026.
Can I use Outlook or Thunderbird with Proton Mail or Tuta?
With Proton Mail, yes, on a paid plan, through the Proton Mail Bridge app. Tuta does not support IMAP or third-party email clients at all, because it says that would mean storing decrypted mail on your device. You use Tuta's own web, desktop and mobile apps instead.
Which is cheaper, Proton Mail or Tuta?
Tuta is cheaper. Its Revolutionary plan costs €3 a month billed yearly, with 20 GB and up to 3 custom domains. Proton Mail Plus costs $29.88 for the first year and then $47.88 a year, with 15 GB and 1 custom domain. Both have free plans with 1 GB of storage.
Is Switzerland or Germany better for email privacy?
Neither is a guarantee. Proton was compelled under Swiss law to log a user's IP address in 2021, and German courts ordered Tuta in 2020 and 2021 to hand over future unencrypted mail for specific accounts. In both cases the end-to-end encrypted content stayed out of reach, which is why the encryption model matters more than the country.
Sources
The specifications, test results and documentation this guide draws on:
- Proton Mail pricing (Proton) — Free, Mail Plus and Unlimited prices, storage, addresses, custom domains and Bridge, checked November 2026
- Proton Mail security features (Proton) — zero-access encryption, PGP, password-protected email, open-source apps, optional post-quantum protection
- Proton Mail brings quantum-safe email encryption to all accounts (Help Net Security) — May 6, 2026; opt-in on all plans, new mail only, pauses end-to-end encrypted forwarding
- Calendar encryption (Proton Support) — event title, description, location and attendees are end-to-end encrypted
- Proton Mail encrypted contacts (Proton blog) — published 2017, updated June 2022; names and email addresses signed but not encrypted, other fields encrypted
- ProtonMail hands user IP address to police (The Register) — September 7, 2021; metadata Proton can access under its privacy policy
- Proton to expand infrastructure beyond Switzerland over surveillance law fears (CyberInsider) — August 13, 2025, updated August 14, 2025 to say Proton is not making a gradual exit from Switzerland
- Inactive accounts (Proton Support) — free accounts inactive for more than 24 months can be deleted; sign in at least once a year; paid accounts are exempt
- Tuta security (Tuta) — subject lines, contacts and calendar encrypted; x25519 plus Kyber-1024; no IMAP; open-source clients; servers in Germany
- Tuta pricing (Tuta) — storage, alias addresses, custom domains and per-user family pricing, checked November 2026
- Tuta vs StartMail (Tuta blog) — August 19, 2026; Revolutionary and Legend monthly and yearly prices in euros
- TutaCrypt post-quantum email encryption passes security analysis (CyberInsider) — August 26, 2026; University of Wuppertal analysis; all accounts migrated by March 2026; no forward secrecy yet
- German court orders Tutanota to monitor a mailbox (The Register) — December 8, 2020; Cologne Regional Court order covering future unencrypted mail for one mailbox
- Tuta launches post-quantum cryptography for email (Tuta blog) — TutaCrypt launch for new accounts, March 2024; published by Tuta
- German court rules Tutanota must monitor messages (CyberScoop) — May 24, 2021; Federal Court of Justice ruling covering two accounts for three months
- Tuta Drive (Tuta) — encrypted cloud storage in closed beta, checked November 2026