Skip to content
PlusReviews

Software & AI ToolsComparison

Proton VPN vs Mullvad (2026): Privacy, Audits, Speed and Price

Proton VPN vs Mullvad for 2026: anonymous sign-up, audits, Swiss vs Swedish law, speed, streaming and pricing, plus who should pick which.

By PlusReviews Editorial TeamPublished 11 min read19 sources

Disclosure: PlusReviews is reader-supported. When you buy through links on this page we may earn an affiliate commission, at no extra cost to you. Our picks are based on independent research. How we make money.

Proton VPN is the better choice for most people, and Mullvad is the better choice if you want the least possible personal data tied to your VPN. In Gizmodo’s November 2026 head-to-head, Proton VPN was faster, unblocked far more streaming services and offered a free plan, 10 devices and more server locations. Mullvad lets you sign up with a random account number and no email, charges one flat €5 a month with no renewal jump, and has a long run of published audits.

Both are among the most trusted names in privacy-focused VPNs. Both publish open-source apps, have had outside auditors examine their systems, and are based in European countries with strong privacy traditions. The real differences are in how much they know about you, how they price their plans and how well they handle everyday jobs like streaming and long-distance connections.

This comparison is research-based. We compared each provider’s pricing pages, payment and policy documents, audit announcements and blog disclosures with independent results, mainly from Gizmodo, as of November 2026. Both VPNs appear in our pillar guide to the best VPN services, where Proton VPN is our best privacy pick and Mullvad is our best pick for anonymity. If you want a VPN mainly for trips abroad, see our guide to the best VPN for travel.

Proton VPN vs Mullvad at a glance (November 2026)
VPNBest forPriceDevicesFree planJurisdictionPrice
Proton VPNPrivacy plus everyday use$71.76 for 2 years, then $83.88 a year (Plus)Up to 10 (1 on free)YesSwitzerlandSee plans at Proton VPN(opens in a new tab)
Mullvad VPNAnonymous sign-up€5 a month, flatUp to 5NoSwedenSee plans at Mullvad VPN(opens in a new tab)

Account and payment privacy

This is where Mullvad is clearly ahead, and it is the main reason people choose it.

Mullvad creates an account with one click and gives you a randomly generated account number. There is no username, no password and no email address. You then add time to that number. Mullvad’s pricing page lists a long range of payment options, including cash, Bitcoin, Bitcoin Cash, Monero, bank wire, cards and PayPal, with a 10% discount for cryptocurrency. For cash, Mullvad says you put the money and a payment token generated on its website in an envelope and post it. It accepts several currencies, including euros, US dollars and pounds.

Proton VPN also accepts more private payment methods. Its support pages say you can pay in Bitcoin from the account dashboard, or send cash by post in Swiss francs, US dollars or euros, with your Proton username in the envelope. The difference is the account itself. According to Gizmodo’s November 2026 review, Proton VPN on computers and iPhones requires a free Proton account with an email address, although the Android app works without one. Gizmodo’s head-to-head lists an email and a payment method as Proton’s sign-up requirements.

So cash is not the dividing line, since both take it. The dividing line is identity: Mullvad never needs to know an email address, while Proton links your VPN to a Proton account. If you already use Proton Mail, that may not bother you. If you want the thinnest possible link between you and your VPN, Mullvad wins.

One trade-off: refunds. Mullvad’s refund window is 14 days, cut from 30 in January 2025, and its terms say cash and cryptocurrency payments are not refundable; Gizmodo reports the same. Proton offers a 30-day money-back guarantee on paid plans, but its support page says subscriptions bought with cash are not refunded either.

Audits, open source and track record

Both providers publish open-source apps, and both have a long record of outside audits.

Proton VPN has had its no-logs policy audited by Securitum in five consecutive years, from 2022 to 2026. CyberInsider reports that the latest on-site review ran from May 20 to 27, 2026, covered free and paid servers, and found that the infrastructure did not retain browsing activity, DNS queries or connection metadata. Gizmodo also notes a SOC 2 Type II attestation in July 2025. As with every audit, Securitum described it as a point-in-time review rather than continuous monitoring.

Mullvad has been audited regularly since 2018, according to Gizmodo. Its blog lists recent work by X41 D-Sec (account and payment services, January 2026), Assured (its GotaTun WireGuard engine, March 2026) and Leviathan Security Group (its Android app, June 2026). Mullvad says every server runs from RAM only, so a restart wipes it. Its no-logs claim has also met a real-world test: in April 2023 Swedish police arrived at its Gothenburg office with a search warrant for computers holding customer data, and Mullvad says they left without taking anything because there was nothing to take.

Mullvad’s record includes a recent disclosure. On May 20, 2026, it reported an exit IP fingerprinting issue that could let websites probabilistically link a user’s sessions after switching servers. It did not reveal identities, and Mullvad rolled out a new way of assigning exit IPs on its servers; its rollout page says the mitigation was on 100% of servers by October 30, 2026. Proton’s best-known legal case involved Proton Mail rather than the VPN: in 2021 Proton said it was legally compelled under Swiss law to log a climate activist’s IP address.

Our take: a tie on trust. Proton has the cleaner run of dedicated no-logs audits, while Mullvad has broader audits of its apps and infrastructure, RAM-only servers and a police visit that came up empty.

Jurisdiction: Switzerland vs Sweden

Neither country is a privacy problem today, but both are debating surveillance rules worth watching.

Proton VPN is based in Switzerland. In 2025 a proposed revision to Switzerland’s surveillance ordinance, known as VÜPF, alarmed privacy companies. According to heise, it would require online services with at least 5,000 users to store metadata such as IP addresses for six months, help authorities decrypt content and identify users. Proton responded in July and August 2025 by saying it would move most of its physical infrastructure out of Switzerland, starting with its Lumo AI assistant on servers in Germany, with new locations in Norway. A Proton spokesperson told TechRadar that investing in Europe did not mean leaving Switzerland.

We found no announcement that Proton VPN’s servers or legal base have moved. On the rule itself, an October 2026 summary from Secria (a competing email and VPN provider, so read it with that in mind) says the revision was not in force and that a second public consultation was forecast for late 2027. If the rule were adopted, Proton’s response would matter more than its current address.

Mullvad is based in Sweden. Gizmodo points out that Sweden belongs to the 14 Eyes intelligence-sharing group, which some privacy buyers avoid on principle. Mullvad’s own legal page, last updated in March 2025, says it is not classed as a communications provider under Swedish law, so the country’s data retention requirements do not apply to it. It adds that foreign authorities would need a mutual assistance agreement or a Swedish or European order to request data. Sweden has also been debating new data retention and encrypted-data access proposals, so this is not settled either.

Our take: roughly even. Switzerland’s proposed rule is the more concrete threat on paper, but Proton has already shown it will move infrastructure in response.

Protocols and security features

Mullvad is WireGuard-only. It began removing OpenVPN in November 2024 and set January 15, 2026 as the date for removing it from all servers and apps. Gizmodo’s October 2026 review confirms OpenVPN is gone. Its desktop apps now use Mullvad’s own GotaTun implementation, and quantum-resistant encryption is on by default. If you rely on an older router or third-party app that only speaks OpenVPN, Mullvad no longer fits.

Proton VPN supports WireGuard, OpenVPN and its own Stealth protocol, plus an automatic setting. Gizmodo notes it does not yet offer post-quantum encryption.

For networks that block VPNs, Proton’s Stealth disguises VPN traffic as ordinary web traffic and is included even on the free plan. Mullvad offers four obfuscation methods: Shadowsocks, UDP-over-TCP, QUIC and Lightweight WireGuard Obfuscation. Gizmodo’s comparison says neither is reliable in China.

Each has its own advanced privacy feature:

  • Proton’s Secure Core (paid plans) sends your traffic through a hardened server in Switzerland, Iceland or Sweden before it exits in your chosen country. It cost about 12% of download speed in Gizmodo’s US test.
  • Mullvad’s DAITA pads traffic and adds dummy packets to resist AI-based traffic analysis, and its multihop lets you pick any two servers.

Proton still offers port forwarding, which Mullvad removed in 2023, which matters if you seed torrents. Mullvad allows P2P on every server, while Proton limits it to P2P servers on paid plans. Gizmodo says Proton’s servers use full-disk encryption with off-site keys, while Mullvad’s run entirely from RAM.

Speed

Gizmodo ran both VPNs on the same 190 Mbps connection, using WireGuard, three times a day for three days.

Server Proton VPN download Mullvad download
UK 178.89 Mbps 180.40 Mbps
US 173.68 Mbps 172.53 Mbps
Japan 159.99 Mbps 125.61 Mbps
Average download loss 10.2% 16.2%
Average upload loss 2.7% 9.6%

On nearby servers the two were effectively tied. Over long distances Proton pulled ahead: Mullvad lost about 34% of its download speed on the Japanese server, and its ping to the US server was roughly double Proton’s (220 ms against 109 ms). These are one tester’s results on one connection, so your numbers will differ, but if you often connect to servers on another continent, Proton has the edge.

Streaming

Proton VPN is the clear winner here. In Gizmodo’s head-to-head it unblocked Netflix in the US, Canada and Japan, plus Prime Video, HBO Max, Peacock, Channel 4 and BBC iPlayer, while missing Hulu, ITVX and Pluto TV. Gizmodo’s separate review reported ITVX working, and its streaming guide counted 10 of 14 services, so expect the exact count to move from month to month.

Mullvad does not promote streaming. In Gizmodo’s tests it unblocked Netflix US and BBC iPlayer but failed on Prime Video, HBO Max and Hulu, and it has no Fire TV or Apple TV app. Proton supports both. Neither offers Smart DNS for smart TVs that cannot run a VPN app.

Remember that watching another country’s catalog usually breaks the streaming service’s terms of use, a point our streaming guide covers in detail.

Free plan

Only Proton VPN has one. Its free plan has no data cap and no ads, according to Gizmodo’s November 2026 pricing, but it is limited to one device, assigns you a server in one of 10 countries with no choice of location, and does not support streaming or torrenting. It is the free VPN we recommend in our free vs paid VPN explainer.

Mullvad has no free plan and no trial. The closest equivalent is paying €5 for a single month and stopping.

Price and renewal

The two use opposite pricing models.

Mullvad charges €5 a month whether you pay for a month, a year or a decade. Its pricing page puts that at about $5.50, VAT included. There is no introductory discount and no renewal increase. Over three years that comes to about €180, or about 10% less if you pay in cryptocurrency.

Proton VPN Plus follows the usual model. Gizmodo’s November 12, 2026 pricing lists:

  • Two-year plan: $71.76 up front ($2.99 a month), or $59.76 during its Black Friday sale.
  • One-year plan: $47.88 up front.
  • Monthly: $9.99.
  • Renewal: both longer plans renew at $83.88 a year, about $6.99 a month.

Gizmodo calculates about $155.64 over three years on the two-year plan plus one renewal. That makes Proton cheaper than Mullvad over that period, but only if you commit for two years up front. Prices vary by region and change with promotions, so check the renewal line at checkout. Our cheap VPN guide compares both against other budget options.

Devices, apps and servers

Proton VPN Mullvad
Simultaneous devices Up to 10 (Plus); 1 (free) Up to 5
Server network (per Gizmodo) 20,000+ servers in 149 countries About 570 servers in 50 countries
TV apps Android TV, Apple TV and Fire TV Android TV only
Refund window 30 days (not on cash) 14 days (not on cash or crypto)

Proton’s larger network matters most for travelers who need a server near where they are or in a specific country. Mullvad’s five-device limit is fine for one person, but tight for a household.

Proton VPN and Mullvad in brief

Best for most people

Proton VPN

Best for Privacy-minded people who also want streaming, travel coverage and several devices

Pick Proton VPN if you want a privacy-first VPN that still works as an everyday VPN for streaming, travel and the whole family’s devices, or if you want to try a free plan first. Skip it if you refuse to give any VPN an email address, or if you dislike paying a higher price after the first term.

Devices
Up to 10 (1 free)
Jurisdiction
Switzerland
Protocols
WireGuard, OpenVPN, Stealth
Refund window
30 days

Pros

  • Five consecutive Securitum no-logs audits, 2022 to 2026
  • Faster than Mullvad on distant servers in Gizmodo's head-to-head
  • Unblocked far more streaming services than Mullvad
  • Free plan with no data cap and no ads, plus Stealth obfuscation on every plan

Cons

  • Needs an account with an email address on computers and iPhones
  • Renews at $83.88 a year after the first term, per Gizmodo
  • No post-quantum encryption yet and no Smart DNS
  • Swiss surveillance proposal still unresolved, though not in force

Best for anonymity

Mullvad VPN

Best for Privacy purists who want no email, cash or crypto payment and one honest price

Pick Mullvad if your priority is keeping your identity separate from your VPN and you value a simple, flat price over extras. Skip it if you stream a lot, need more than five devices, connect to distant servers often, or want a free plan. Mullvad does not run an affiliate program, so this link goes straight to its site.

Devices
Up to 5
Jurisdiction
Sweden
Protocol
WireGuard only
Refund window
14 days

Pros

  • Random account number with no email, password or username
  • Flat €5 a month with no renewal increase and no contract
  • RAM-only servers, regular published audits and a 2023 police visit that found no customer data
  • Post-quantum encryption on by default, DAITA and four obfuscation methods

Cons

  • Weak for streaming, with no Fire TV or Apple TV app
  • Only 5 devices and about 50 countries
  • WireGuard only, so OpenVPN-only routers and apps no longer work
  • 14-day refund window, with no refunds on cash or crypto payments

Who should pick which

  • Journalists, activists and anyone who wants no account trail: Mullvad, for its numbered accounts and cash payments.
  • Privacy-minded streamers: Proton VPN. It unblocked far more services in Gizmodo’s tests.
  • Frequent travelers: Proton VPN, for its larger server network, better long-distance speeds and Stealth. Our best VPN for travel guide compares it with other options.
  • People on a tight budget: Proton VPN if you will commit for two years, or Proton Free if you only need one device. Mullvad if you want to pay month to month with no lock-in.
  • Torrenting: Proton VPN if you need port forwarding; Mullvad if you only need P2P on any server.
  • Households with many devices: Proton VPN, or look at Surfshark in our NordVPN vs Surfshark comparison.

How we researched this comparison

We did not run our own speed or streaming tests. We compared Proton VPN and Mullvad using Mullvad’s pricing page, legal page, audit posts and blog disclosures, Proton’s payment support documentation, published audit coverage, and independent reviews and head-to-head results from Gizmodo, all checked in November 2026. Where sources disagreed, such as Proton’s exact streaming count, we say so. For the Swiss surveillance proposal we relied on press coverage of Proton’s 2025 announcement and a dated summary of the rule’s status, and we label that summary’s publisher as a competitor. Proton VPN has an affiliate program and Mullvad does not; that did not affect the verdict. See our editorial policy and affiliate disclosure.

Bottom line

Proton VPN is the better all-round VPN: faster over distance, much better for streaming, larger network, more devices and a free plan worth using, all backed by five years of no-logs audits. Mullvad is the better choice for one specific job, which is keeping your identity out of the picture, with a flat price that never jumps. If anonymity is your priority, choose Mullvad. If you want privacy and a VPN that handles everything else too, choose Proton VPN.

See Proton VPN's current plans(opens in a new tab) Visit Mullvad at Mullvad VPN(opens in a new tab)

Frequently asked questions

Is Proton VPN or Mullvad better for privacy?

Mullvad collects less about you. You sign up with a random account number and no email, and you can pay in cash by post. Proton VPN also has a strong record, with five consecutive Securitum no-logs audits from 2022 to 2026 and open-source apps, but on computers and iPhones it needs an account with an email address.

Is Proton VPN faster than Mullvad?

In Gizmodo's November 2026 head-to-head on the same 190 Mbps connection, Proton VPN lost 10.2% of download speed on average against 16.2% for Mullvad. The gap was widest on a distant Japanese server, where Mullvad lost about a third of its speed.

Does Mullvad have a free plan?

No. Mullvad charges a flat €5 a month and has no free tier. Proton VPN has a free plan with no data cap and no ads, limited to one device and a server it picks for you in one of 10 countries.

Which is cheaper, Proton VPN or Mullvad?

Over two or three years, Proton VPN usually is. Gizmodo's November 2026 pricing lists Proton VPN Plus at $71.76 for the first two years, then $83.88 a year, about $156 over three years. Mullvad's flat €5 a month comes to about €180 over three years, but you can stop any month and never face a renewal jump.

Is Proton VPN leaving Switzerland?

Not as a company. In 2025 Proton said it would move most of its physical infrastructure out of Switzerland, starting with its Lumo AI assistant in Germany, because of a proposed Swiss surveillance rule. Proton VPN is still Swiss-based, and the proposed rule was not in force as of late 2026.

Sources

The specifications, test results and documentation this guide draws on:

  1. Mullvad vs Proton VPN (Gizmodo) — published November 12, 2026; same-tester speed test, streaming, sign-up, features and refunds
  2. Proton VPN review (Gizmodo) — published November 18, 2026; Securitum audits 2022 to 2026, Stealth, free plan, account and payment options
  3. Mullvad VPN review (Gizmodo) — published October 17, 2026; audit history, obfuscation methods, 14-day refund
  4. Proton VPN pricing (Gizmodo) — published November 12, 2026; $71.76 for 24 months, renewal at $83.88 a year, three-year totals
  5. Pricing (Mullvad) — flat €5 a month, 5 devices, cash by post, 10% crypto discount
  6. Payment methods (Proton VPN support) — Bitcoin and cash by post in CHF, USD or EUR; no refunds on cash purchases
  7. Removing OpenVPN, 15th January 2026 (Mullvad) — Mullvad moves to WireGuard only
  8. External audits (Mullvad blog) — 2025 and 2026 audits by X41 D-Sec, Assured, Leviathan Security Group and NCC Group
  9. Exit IP fingerprinting between VPN servers (Mullvad) — May 20, 2026 disclosure and planned server-side mitigation
  10. Exit IP mitigation rollout (Mullvad) — last updated November 5, 2026; mitigation on 100% of servers as of October 30, 2026
  11. Terms of service (Mullvad) — last updated January 20, 2026; 14-day money-back guarantee, no refunds for cash or crypto payments
  12. For privacy: change of our refund policy from 30 to 14 days (Mullvad) — January 31, 2025; 14-day window for new payments
  13. Mullvad VPN was subject to a search warrant (Mullvad) — April 2023; Swedish police left without customer data
  14. Swedish legislation relevant to us as a VPN provider (Mullvad) — last updated March 11, 2025; Mullvad says Swedish data retention rules do not apply to it
  15. Proton VPN passes fifth no-logs audit (CyberInsider) — Securitum on-site review, May 20 to 27, 2026
  16. Proton relocates parts of its infrastructure from Switzerland (heise online) — August 16, 2025; proposed VÜPF amendments, Lumo servers in Germany, sites in Norway
  17. Important clarifications regarding arrest of climate activist (Proton) — 2021; Proton Mail compelled under Swiss law to log an IP address
  18. Experts urge the Swedish Parliament to reject the encryption backdoor law (TechRadar) — Swedish data retention and encrypted-data access proposal
  19. Is Proton leaving Switzerland? Where things stand in 2026 (Secria) — October 31, 2026; status of the Swiss rule change; published by a competing email and VPN provider