Skip to content
PlusReviews

Tech & GadgetsComparison

Home Assistant vs SmartThings (2026): Local Control, Matter, Cost

Home Assistant vs SmartThings in late 2026: local control, Matter and Thread, setup effort, automations, hub costs and the new SmartThings API fee explained.

By PlusReviews Editorial TeamPublished 8 min read14 sources

Disclosure: PlusReviews is reader-supported. When you buy through links on this page we may earn an affiliate commission, at no extra cost to you. Our picks are based on independent research. How we make money.

Home Assistant is the better smart home platform for most people who care about local control, privacy and flexibility. It runs your automations on a small computer in your home, works with thousands of brands, and keeps working when the internet goes down. SmartThings is the better choice if you want the easiest setup or already own Samsung TVs and appliances, many of which include a SmartThings hub. It is free to use, but its new cloud API fee, which started on November 4, 2026, ends the free link between the two platforms.

If you are still choosing between ecosystems such as Alexa, Apple Home and Google Home, start with our guide on how to choose a smart home hub, where Home Assistant Green is our pick for local control. This comparison is for people deciding between the two platforms that most often appeal to tinkerers and Samsung owners.

This comparison is research-based. We read both platforms’ official documentation and announcements, hardware specifications and expert coverage as of November 19, 2026. We did not test either platform ourselves.

Home Assistant vs SmartThings at a glance
Home AssistantSmartThings
Software costFree, open sourceFree app; paid plans only for direct cloud API use
Hub hardwareHome Assistant Green ($199) or your own PC, mini PC or Raspberry PiAeotec Smart Home Hub 2 ($119.99) or a Samsung TV, fridge or monitor with a built-in hub
Where automations runLocally, on your hubLocally for hub-connected devices; cloud for Wi-Fi and cloud integrations
Zigbee and ThreadWith a Connect ZBT-2 ($49) or other USB adapterBuilt into Hub 2; not in every built-in Samsung hub
Z-WaveWith a USB adapter such as the Connect ZWA-2Not on Hub 2; the original Aeotec Smart Home Hub has it
MatterYes, as a controllerYes; first major platform with Matter 1.5 cameras
Setup effortModerate to highLow
Remote accessFree to set up yourself, or via paid Nabu Casa serviceIncluded through the Samsung cloud

Local control and reliability

Home Assistant is local-first. The software runs on hardware you own, and automations such as “turn on the hallway light when motion is detected after sunset” run there. If your internet connection drops, devices connected through local radios or local network integrations keep working. Remote access and voice assistants are optional layers on top.

SmartThings has moved a long way toward local control. Its Edge drivers run on the hub, and routines that involve hub-connected devices can run without the cloud. In November 2026, SmartThings said its app now talks directly to supported hubs when your phone is on the home network, including the 2018 SmartThings Hub, the Aeotec Smart Home Hub 2, SmartThings Station and newer Samsung TVs and Bespoke appliances with built-in hubs. SmartThings is clear about the limits: Wi-Fi devices that connect through the cloud and cloud-to-cloud partner integrations still need an internet connection, and away-from-home control always goes through the cloud.

In practice, both can run core lighting and sensor automations locally if your devices connect through the hub. Home Assistant extends that to far more device types and does not depend on a company’s servers for setup or remote access.

Matter and Thread

Both platforms work as Matter controllers, which means a Matter light or plug can join either one, or both at once through Matter’s multi-admin feature.

SmartThings has been quicker with new Matter features. Matter Alpha reported in December 2025 that SmartThings was the first major platform to support Matter 1.5 cameras, while Home Assistant was still reworking its Matter implementation. SmartThings’ older hubs, including the 2015 and 2018 SmartThings hubs and the original Aeotec Smart Home Hub, also gained Thread 1.4 features such as sharing one Thread network with other platforms in a firmware update that began rolling out in September 2025. Matter Alpha reported that the Hub 2 was not yet included at the time.

Home Assistant’s Thread support depends on your hardware. Home Assistant Green has no radios, so you add a Connect ZBT-2 adapter, which runs either Zigbee or Thread, not both at once. Nabu Casa recommends one adapter per protocol and still describes Thread support on the ZBT-2 as under development on its Green page.

One catch with SmartThings: Samsung says some built-in hubs in TVs and appliances are software-only and support Matter over Wi-Fi but not Zigbee or Thread. Check your model before assuming your TV can replace a dedicated hub.

Setup effort and day-to-day use

SmartThings is the easier start. Install the app, sign in with a Samsung account, and Samsung devices often appear automatically. Adding a Zigbee or Matter device is a guided process, and routines are built with simple “if this, then that” screens.

Home Assistant has improved a lot, with a visual automation editor, auto-discovery of many devices on your network and plug-in hardware in Green. It still asks more of you: deciding which integrations to use, naming and organizing devices, and occasionally reading release notes before updating. The reward is control that SmartThings cannot match.

Automations

SmartThings routines handle the common cases well: schedules, sunrise and sunset, device states, location and modes such as Home and Away. They are quick to build in the app.

Home Assistant automations go much further. You can combine triggers, conditions and actions in any order, use templates and variables, reuse community “blueprints”, build scripts and scenes, and create custom dashboards for wall tablets. It can also pull in data that SmartThings cannot reach, such as energy prices, local weather stations or a self-hosted camera system. If you plan to add cameras, our guide to the best security cameras without a subscription covers models that work with Home Assistant over local streams.

Cost

Home Assistant: the software is free. The plug-and-play Home Assistant Green has a suggested price of $199 after Nabu Casa raised it in 2026 because of higher memory costs. Add $49 for a Connect ZBT-2 if you need Zigbee or Thread, and a Z-Wave adapter such as the Connect ZWA-2 if you use Z-Wave locks or switches. Nabu Casa’s optional subscription, being renamed Home Assistant Link on December 2, 2026, adds easy remote access and Alexa and Google Assistant links and funds development, but none of that is required.

SmartThings: the app is free. The Aeotec Smart Home Hub 2 is listed at $119.99 by Samsung, and you may not need it at all if you own a recent Samsung TV or appliance with a built-in hub that has the radios your devices need. The only new cost is for direct cloud API access, which most people never touch, unless they connect SmartThings to Home Assistant or other third-party tools.

The SmartThings API fee and Home Assistant users

Samsung first announced paid SmartThings API plans in June 2026, as Matter Alpha reported on June 27. In an October 30, 2026 update, SmartThings confirmed that developers and individuals calling its cloud APIs directly would move to paid plans from November 4, 2026. Already-installed integrations keep working until December 15, 2026, after which unpaid access may be limited or paused. SmartThings says the app, in-app routines, local Edge drivers, hub integrations and Matter devices stay free.

Home Assistant’s SmartThings integration is a cloud integration, so it is affected. SmartThings calls the individual tier its Developer Plan; Home Assistant’s documentation calls it the Personal Plan and lists it at $4.99 a month. Matter Alpha reported in June 2026 that about 9.8% of Home Assistant installs that share analytics used the integration.

If you use both platforms, you have three options:

  1. Pay for the SmartThings plan to keep the cloud integration.
  2. Move Matter devices with multi-admin. Generate a new pairing code in SmartThings and add the device to Home Assistant’s Matter integration. It then no longer depends on the SmartThings API.
  3. Move Zigbee and Z-Wave devices to an adapter that Home Assistant controls. This means re-pairing devices and rebuilding automations.

Samsung appliances such as washers and refrigerators are the hard case, because they usually reach Home Assistant only through the SmartThings cloud.

Hardware for each platform

Hubs for Home Assistant and SmartThings
HubPlatformBuilt-in radiosSuggested pricePrice
Home Assistant GreenHome AssistantNone; add USB adapters$199Check price at Amazon(opens in a new tab)
Aeotec Smart Home Hub 2SmartThingsZigbee, Thread, Matter$119.99Check price at Amazon(opens in a new tab)

Best for Home Assistant

Home Assistant Green

Best for Anyone starting with Home Assistant who wants plug-in hardware rather than a DIY computer

Green is the simplest way into Home Assistant. You plug it into your router, open a browser and follow the setup. Pair it with a Connect ZBT-2 for Zigbee or Thread devices, as our smart home hub guide explains.

See the Connect ZBT-2 adapter at Amazon(opens in a new tab)

Who should skip it: people who want a finished app experience with no learning curve, and households that rely on Samsung appliances that only connect through SmartThings.

Processor
Rockchip RK3566, quad-core
Memory
4GB RAM, 32GB eMMC
Radios
None built in
Price
$199 suggested (US, before tax)

Pros

  • Home Assistant preinstalled on fanless hardware
  • Automations run locally and keep working without internet
  • Low power use, about 1.7W idle according to Nabu Casa
  • No subscription required

Cons

  • No built-in Zigbee, Thread or Z-Wave; adapters cost extra
  • Suggested price rose to $199 in 2026
  • Steeper learning curve than SmartThings
  • Gigabit Ethernet only, no Wi-Fi

Best for SmartThings

Aeotec Smart Home Hub 2

Best for SmartThings users without a Samsung TV or appliance that already includes a full hub

The Hub 2 arrived in the US in November 2025 as the successor to the Aeotec Smart Home Hub. It is about half the size of its predecessor and, according to Android Central’s launch coverage, runs more tasks locally. It makes sense if you want SmartThings with Zigbee and Thread devices but do not own a Samsung TV or appliance with those radios built in.

Who should skip it: anyone with Z-Wave locks or switches, and anyone planning to connect SmartThings to Home Assistant through the cloud.

Radios
Zigbee, Thread, Matter
Memory
512MB RAM
Price
$119.99 (Samsung US)
Platform
SmartThings

Pros

  • Zigbee, Thread and Matter in one small hub
  • Supports SmartThings local control in the app
  • Faster processor and double the RAM of the previous model, according to Samsung
  • Built-in Thread border router for Matter-over-Thread devices, per SmartThings

Cons

  • No Z-Wave radio, unlike the previous Aeotec hub
  • US availability has been patchy; Samsung is the main seller
  • Samsung store owner reviews averaged 2.4 out of 5 from 21 reviews in November 2026
  • Wi-Fi and cloud-connected devices still need the internet
  • Fewer integrations and less automation depth than Home Assistant

Who should pick which

  • Pick Home Assistant if you own devices from many brands, want automations that survive internet outages, care about keeping data at home, or enjoy tuning your setup. It is also the realistic choice for Z-Wave users who want a single platform.
  • Pick SmartThings if your home is full of Samsung TVs, appliances and Galaxy phones, you want setup to take minutes rather than evenings, and you are comfortable with some cloud dependence.
  • Pick neither yet if you mainly use one voice assistant. Alexa, Apple Home and Google Home may be enough, as our smart home hub guide explains.

A smart home also depends on a solid network. If devices drop off Wi-Fi, see our guide to the best mesh Wi-Fi systems, several of which include Thread radios.

How we researched this comparison

We did not test these platforms ourselves. We read SmartThings’ official blog posts from October and November 2026 on API plans, local control and Hub Everywhere, Home Assistant’s documentation for its SmartThings integration, Green hardware and Connect adapters, and Nabu Casa’s pricing announcements. We relied on Android Central and Matter Alpha for launch details and Matter and Thread developments. We also searched the US Consumer Product Safety Commission recall database for the hubs mentioned and found no recalls.

SmartThings’ API changes were still rolling out when we published, and Home Assistant releases monthly updates, so check both projects’ current documentation before making changes. Our editorial policy explains how we research, and our affiliate disclosure explains how we earn money from links.

Bottom line

Home Assistant is the stronger platform for anyone who wants local control, broad device support and powerful automations, and Home Assistant Green is the easiest way to start. SmartThings is the friendlier choice for Samsung households and people who want a smart home that works out of the box. If you already run both, move shared Matter devices over with multi-admin before December 15, 2026, or budget for the SmartThings Developer Plan.

Check Home Assistant Green price on Amazon(opens in a new tab)

Frequently asked questions

Is Home Assistant better than SmartThings?

For local control, flexibility and device support, yes. Home Assistant runs automations on hardware in your home and integrates with thousands of brands. SmartThings is easier to set up and is the better fit for Samsung households, because many Samsung TVs, refrigerators and monitors already include a SmartThings hub.

Does SmartThings work without the internet?

Partly. Routines and devices connected through a SmartThings hub can run locally, and since late 2026 the SmartThings app can control hub-connected devices directly over your home network. Wi-Fi devices that connect through the cloud, and cloud-to-cloud integrations, stop working during an internet outage.

Is SmartThings charging for the Home Assistant integration?

Effectively, yes. SmartThings moved direct cloud API access to paid plans on November 4, 2026 and says unpaid API access may be paused from December 15, 2026. Home Assistant's SmartThings integration uses that cloud API, and Home Assistant's documentation lists the individual plan, which it calls the Personal Plan, at $4.99 a month. The SmartThings app, hubs and local integrations stay free.

Can I use Home Assistant and SmartThings together?

Yes. Matter devices can be shared with both platforms through Matter's multi-admin feature, which does not depend on the SmartThings cloud API. Zigbee and Z-Wave devices can only pair with one hub at a time, so they must live on one platform.

How much does Home Assistant cost?

The software is free. Nabu Casa's Home Assistant Green hub has a suggested price of $199 after a 2026 increase, and Zigbee or Thread needs the $49 Connect ZBT-2 adapter. An optional Nabu Casa subscription adds easy remote access and voice assistant links.

Sources

The specifications, test results and documentation this guide draws on:

  1. SmartThings API additional details for developers and business partners (SmartThings) — October 30, 2026; paid API plans from November 4, access may be paused from December 15; app and local integrations stay free
  2. SmartThings Local Control (SmartThings) — November 5, 2026; app talks directly to supported hubs at home; limits during outages
  3. SmartThings Hub Replace and Hub Everywhere (SmartThings) — November 13, 2026; hub features in TVs, fridges and monitors; some built-in hubs lack Zigbee and Thread
  4. SmartThings integration (Home Assistant documentation) — cloud push integration; paid Personal Plan listed at $4.99 a month
  5. Samsung's new SmartThings hub hits US shelves (Android Central) — November 16, 2025; Aeotec Smart Home Hub 2, $120, Zigbee, Thread and Matter, no Z-Wave
  6. Aeotec Smart Home Hub 2 (Samsung US) — listed at $119.99 in November 2026
  7. Aeotec Smart Home Hub (Aeotec) — original SmartThings hub: Zigbee, Z-Wave (up to 100 devices, S2), Matter and Thread border router
  8. Home Assistant Green (Home Assistant) — specs, $199 suggested price, no built-in radios
  9. Home Assistant Green pricing change (Nabu Casa) — January 8, 2026, updated April 24, 2026; price raised to $199 because of memory costs
  10. Home Assistant Connect ZBT-2 (Home Assistant) — $49; Zigbee or Thread, one at a time
  11. SmartThings announces Matter 1.5 camera support (Matter Alpha) — December 9, 2025; first major platform with Matter cameras; Home Assistant not yet
  12. Samsung puts a $5 paywall on Home Assistant integration (Matter Alpha) — June 27, 2026; about 9.8% of opted-in Home Assistant installs used the SmartThings integration
  13. Home Assistant Cloud (Home Assistant) — optional remote access and voice assistant service; renaming to Home Assistant Link on December 2, 2026
  14. SmartThings hubs upgrade to Thread 1.4 with credential sharing (Matter Alpha) — September 24, 2025; firmware 0.58.10 for 2015 and 2018 hubs and the original Aeotec hub; Hub 2 not yet included